Book Review – Page 2 – History and Mystery Reads

Roots (1976), Alex Haley

Rating: 6/10 Accuracy: Presented as family history, but genealogists have challenged many claims, and Haley settled…

Rating: 6/10 · Translated from Spanish Accuracy: Uses real history, especially Philip II and the Spanish…

Rating: 7/10 Accuracy: Loosely based on William Adams and Tokugawa Ieyasu around 1600, with names changed…

Rating: 8/10 Accuracy: Deliberately mixes real historical figures with invented events, blurring fact and fiction. Readability:…

Rating: 9/10 · Translated from Italian (original title La Storia); English edition 1977 Accuracy: Firmly grounded…

Rating: 7/10 · Translated from Spanish (original title El recurso del método) Accuracy: A composite Latin…

Rating: 8/10 · Translated from Spanish (original title Yo el Supremo) Accuracy: Built on documents and…

Rating: 9/10 Accuracy: Faithful to the known movements and decisions at Gettysburg, with inner lives imagined…

Rating: 9/10 Accuracy: Closely modelled on real sieges of 1857, especially Lucknow, with details drawn from…

Rating: 9/10 Accuracy: Well researched, with real documents and events, but Burr’s opinions of the Founding…

Rating: 8/10 Accuracy: Faithful to the ancient sources on Alexander’s campaigns in Persia and India, with…

Rating: 6/10 · Translated from Russian Accuracy: Exhaustive on the Russian defeat at Tannenberg, drawing on…